Recent Ontario Decision Raises Potential for Wallace Damages
Terminating an employee for cause is one of the highest-risk decisions an employer can make in the employment relationship. This is because the financial consequences for a termination that is found to be unfair or in bad faith can, and often do, extend well beyond the employee’s standard entitlement. A recent Ontario Superior Court decision serves as a striking reminder that the reason for termination is one of, if not the most important, part of the termination process.
In Wilsher v. Olympic Wholesale, 2026 ONSC 3620, the Court awarded a terminated employee the equivalent of 33 months’ pay in lieu of notice; 19 months for reasonable notice, plus a further 14 months of Wallace damages. The employee, a 55-year-old with 17 years of service, was dismissed for willful misconduct after manually “topping up” employees’ timesheets. The employer characterized the conduct as fraud and time theft, while the employee had argued that “topping up” shifts was a longstanding practice within the company. The Court overturned the termination, determining that the employee was taught how to “top up” during training. The “topping up” practice had existed for years and continued after the employee’s termination and the employee herself never benefited from the “topping up”.
The Court in Wilsher relied on the decision in McKinley v. BC Tel and Wallace v. United Grain Growers Ltd. instead, which determined that a notice period may be extended as compensation for an employer’s bad faith or unfairly treatment of an employee in the course of dismissal. This is particularly concerning for employers because it re-opens the door to the possibility of damages being tied to automatic extensions of notice periods rather than tying compensation to the actual harm suffered, by way of aggravated, punitive, or general damages.
Additionally, the decision is significant for employers because it signals that courts may be prepared to move beyond the traditional 24-month presumptive ceiling for reasonable notice, even in the absence of truly exceptional circumstances. The 33-month notice period introduces a greater uncertainty into termination liability and highlights the need for employers to carefully assess notice obligations when making termination decisions.
Key Takeaways for Employers
Moving forward, to avoid having to pay out lengthy and unwarranted notice periods, employers should:
- Carefully investigate the employee’s conduct/actions and whether they were consistent with workplace practices;
- Consider all past training the employee has done; and
- Ensure the termination is handled fairly, respectfully, and with all policies/evidence to support it.
