Ontario Court of Appeal Finds “at any time” and “for any reason” Language Consistent with the ESA

The decision in Baker v. Van Dolder’s Home Team Inc.; Li v. Wayfair Canada ULC, 2026 ONCA 568 has finally given employers some welcomed clarity on a recurring employment law headache regarding when a termination clause is in violation of the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA).

This Ontario Court of Appeal case considered two appeals involving their respective termination provisions; one that permitted termination “at any time” and the other that permitted termination “at any time and for any reason.” The Court unanimously rejected the argument that these words, standing alone, make a termination clause unenforceable and emphasized that employment contracts must be interpreted as a whole, with an understanding of what the parties intended in their surrounding circumstances.

In Baker v. Van Dolder, the employee’s contract provided for termination without cause “at any time,” and limited the employee’s entitlements to the minimum entitlements required by the ESA. On appeal from a motion judge’s ruling who found the provision to be unenforceable, the Court held that the wording was, in fact, consistent with the ESA. In particular, the Court interpreted “at any time” to mean that the employer could terminate the employee at any point it chose, subject to the statutory requirements. It did not mean the employer had a right to disregard these restrictions on termination.

The second appeal, Li v. Wayfair Canada ULC, involved a provision allowing termination “at any time and for any reason.” The Court also found the language enforceable when read in the context of the agreement as a whole. Importantly, the Court rejected a highly literal approach that treated isolated words such as “any time” or “any reason” as automatically invalid. Instead, the question that should be before courts is what the parties objectively intended for the contract to mean.

Baker and Li move Ontario employment law away from a literal approach with respect to termination clauses and towards a more practical, whole-contract analysis. Despite this win for employers, the drafting strategy remains the same. Always draft carefully, expressly preserve ESA minimums, and have termination language reviewed before relying on it.