Corporate Structure Won’t Shield Employers from Common Employer Doctrine

A recent Ontario Court of Appeal decision serves as a caution to employers who are interrelated with another legal entity, but wish to treated as distinct for liability purposes. Overlapping control of employee matters between interrelated legal entities may result in the entities being deemed a common employer for the purposes of employment obligations and liability.

In Boyce Estate v. 2113626 Ontario Inc. (Hampton Inn and Suites), the employee was hired as a hotel manager under a three-year fixed-term contract. Her employment was terminated after five months. The employee subsequently brought a wrongful dismissal claim against the company that operated one part of the defendant’s family business. The operating company was found to be her employer and was ordered to pay $120,000 in damages. However, it was ultimately unable to satisfy the judgment. The employee then pursued a claim against the defendant’s related property company, arguing that it was also her common employer.

The claim proceeded by way of summary judgment. The motion judge applied the common employer doctrine in finding that the defendant’s related property company was, in fact, a common employer and therefore jointly liable to satisfy payment of the original judgment.

The common employer doctrine permits a court, in appropriate circumstances, to treat separate but related legal entities as a single employer for the purposes of determining liability for employment-related obligations, including outstanding wages, termination pay and severance pay.

In upholding the motion judge’s decision, the Court of Appeal confirmed the two-part test for determining application of the common employer doctrine:

  • First, the court must determine whether there is a significant degree of interrelationship and common control between or among the alleged common employers; and
  • Second, the court must assess whether the employee held a reasonable expectation that the other companies or entities were party to their employment contract.

On the first prong of the test applicable to the common employer doctrine, the two interrelated businesses were found to have overlapping control and were both involved in the same hotel operations.

On the second prong of the test, the Court examined conduct related to hiring, payment of wages, method of work, and ability to dismiss, among others, in finding that the employee had a reasonable expectation that both businesses were party to the employment contract.

The decision sends a clear message to employers: the common employer doctrine looks to the realities of the employment relationship and assigns liability accordingly. Where affiliated companies share various aspects of the employment relationship, such as management, HR and payroll, and operational control, the distinction between the entities may become less meaningful from an employment law perspective.

Moving forward, employers who operate multiple corporate affiliations but wish to ensure their businesses remain legally separate should clearly define which corporation employs, signs employment agreements, oversees payroll, supervises, etc.  If multiple entities are actively involved in an employee’s relationship, employers should take steps to ensure clear lines of liability are maintained.