Kondaj v. Crossbridge Condominium Services Ltd

The decision in Kondaj v. Crossbridge Condominium Services Ltd., serves as a cautionary reminder that when employers undergo contract changes specific to building service providers, the incoming provider may inherit more than just the contract itself. Wrongful dismissal claims may also flow from the change.

The case arose after the SoHo Hotel & Residences Shared Facilities replaced Crossbridge Condominium Services Ltd. with Duka Property Management Inc. as its property management provider. Mr. Kondaj, who worked as a building manager, was not retained by Duka when they took over the contract, and Crossbridge chose to not reassign him to another property. Although Duka paid Mr. Kondaj his statutory termination entitlements, neither company provided him with common law reasonable notice, with each arguing that the other was responsible for doing so. The motion judge held Duka liable for 10 months’ reasonable notice, amounting to $78,925, as well as damages in lieu of lost benefits and Duka appealed.

The Ontario Court of Appeal reaffirmed the motion judge’s decision and determined that it is the responsibility of the new building service provider to pay the terminated employee’s common law reasonable notice entitlements if that new building service provider does not retain the employee of the previous provider.

The Court of Appeal upheld the motion judge’s interpretation of the ESA’s building services provisions, whereby an incoming building service provider can be liable for more than just the minimum termination payments required under the ESA.

This decision is a significant warning for building service providers and should reinforce the following:

  • Treat employee transitions as a core part of every building service contract change;
  • Incoming building providers must assess what their common law exposure will be under the ESA before enacting workforce changes; and
  • Outgoing building providers should review and address any workforce transition responsibilities in their agreements.