Ontario Labour Relation Board’s New Guidance on “Appropriate” Workplace Investigations

A recent decision marks the first time that the Ontario Labour Relations Board (the “Board”) considered the scope of the duties imposed on employers regarding workplace harassment investigations under the Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA). Critically, the Board’s decision offers procedural guidance on how to undertake a workplace harassment investigation that meets the OHSA requirement to be “appropriate in circumstances”.

In Alyssa Gassi v. The Corporation of the County of Lambton, the Applicant reported a complaint alleging that she was being harassed in the workplace. The complaint was investigated by the employer and was found not to be supported. The Applicant’s employment was terminated thereafter for reasons the employer claimed were unrelated to her workplace harassment complaint. The Applicant filed a complaint with the Ministry of Labour asserting that the investigation was “not appropriate in the circumstances” as required by the OHSA. The Inspector declined to issue any Orders in relation to the Applicant’s Ministry of Labour complaint. The Applicant appealed the Inspector’s decision to the Board and further advanced a reprisal application asserting that she was terminated for exercising her right under the OHSA to report workplace harassment.

The Board found that the employer successfully demonstrated that Applicant’s termination was not due to her harassment complaint, but rather her performance and conduct issues. While the proximity in time between when the Applicant made her complaint of harassment and her termination attracted greater scrutiny, the Board found that proximity in time alone was not sufficient to establish reprisal.

Despite its determination that the employer did not reprise against the Applicant, the Board found that the workplace harassment investigation was not “appropriate in the circumstances” for three reasons:

  1. The internal investigator unilaterally decided to only meet with one witness (out of many) to determine that the Applicant’s complaint was unfounded;
  2. The investigator did not explain his reasoning why only meeting with one witness was sufficient enough; and
  3. The investigator did not give the Applicant an opportunity to respond to the information that the investigator uncovered notwithstanding his representation to her that she would be able to do so.

The decision offers valuable guidance for employers when conducting an “appropriate” workplace investigation, including:

  1. Investigation must balance the rights and interests of all parties involved and that the investigation is procedurally fair;
  2. Employers do not necessarily need to hire a third-party investigator in every instance, so long as the internal investigator is impartial, has some understanding of workplace harassment and OHSA provisions, and ideally has some knowledge of workplace investigations;
  3. Investigators do not necessarily need to look into every allegation or require every named person in the complaint to be interviewed as long as it is justified; and
  4. Investigators need not provide a copy of the entire investigative report to the complainant but must inform the complainant of the investigation results in writing.

Moving forward, the key takeaway for employers should be to use a well-documented, thoughtfully conducted investigation as one of your strongest risk management tools. Investing in OHSA and workplace harassment training for your investigators, following a consistent process, and carefully documenting reasons for the decisions can help ensure your workplace investigations withstand legal scrutiny.